Selling online feels weird sometimes, right? You want to grow your business, but you don’t want to come off as pushy or desperate.

The truth? The best sales don’t feel like sales at all. The brands and people that succeed on social media today aren’t just trying to close deals, they’re building relationships, trust, and authority.

So how do you actually sell on social media in a way that feels natural and leads to consistent revenue? Let’s break it down.

1. Lead with Value Before You Sell

If your social media strategy is all about “buy this, sign up for that,” it’s time for a shift. People don’t log onto social media looking for sales pitches, they’re there to connect, learn, and be entertained.

The secret? Give first before you ask for anything. Share useful tips, educate your audience, or offer solutions to their biggest problems. When people see you as a valuable resource, they’ll trust you more and trust is what turns followers into buyers.

✅ Teach them something useful

✅ Share behind-the-scenes insights

✅ Offer quick, actionable solutions to common problems

The more valuable your content, the more likely people will engage with you, stick around, and eventually buy.

2. Tell Stories, Not Sales Pitches

No one likes feeling like they’re being sold to, but everyone loves a good story. Instead of saying, “My service will help you get more leads,” try showing them how it worked for someone else.

For example:

❌ “Our social media marketing service helps businesses grow.”

✅ “One of my clients was struggling to get engagement on their posts. After tweaking their content strategy, they saw a 300% increase in comments and a spike in inbound inquiries. Here’s exactly what we did…”

Stories are powerful because they create curiosity, emotion, and relatability. When people see how others benefit from your services, they naturally want the same results.

3. Use Social Proof to Sell for You

Ever tried a new restaurant just because your friend raved about it? That’s social proof in action. People are far more likely to trust a recommendation from a real person than a direct sales pitch.

Instead of constantly promoting yourself, let happy clients and customers do the talking.

✅ Share testimonials from satisfied clients

✅ Post screenshots of positive feedback

✅ Repost user-generated content showcasing your work

When others vouch for your expertise, your audience sees your value in action and that’s often all the convincing they need.

4. Sell in the Comments and DMs, Not Just Your Posts

Your social media posts might spark interest, but the real conversions happen in the comments and direct messages. Social selling is about starting conversations, not just broadcasting messages.

If someone leaves a comment saying, “I struggle with getting engagement,” don’t just “like” it, reply with a helpful tip or ask a follow-up question. This creates a real connection and can open the door for a deeper conversation (which could lead to a sale).

💡 Engage with your audience, reply to comments and start conversations

💡 Ask questions that spark discussion

💡 Offer help in the DMs in a way that feels natural, not forced

Your best leads might not come from people who like your post, they come from those who start talking to you because they see you as someone who can help.

5. Create Urgency But Without the Pressure

Urgency is a powerful sales tool, but if done wrong, it can feel manipulative. Instead of using scare tactics like “BUY NOW BEFORE IT’S TOO LATE!” (which often turns people off), frame your offers in a way that feels genuine and logical.

For example:

✅ “I only take on five new clients per month, and spots are filling up fast. If you’re thinking about working together, now’s a great time to reach out.”

✅ “This special bonus is only available for the next 48 hours!”

Scarcity works because it taps into human psychology, but it should be used honestly. If people feel they’ll miss out, they’ll be more likely to take action.

Selling on social media isn’t about pushing it’s about attracting. When you lead with value, build trust, and create genuine conversations, sales happen naturally. I talked about this in my LinkedIn Community and they are talking about how they love or hate social selling. Join the conversation here.

Want exclusive bonus tips and two extra social selling techniques that make closing deals easier?

📩 Subscribe to the NLMM Insider Newsletter and get 2 bonus sales techniques I only share with my email subscribers. If you like to know about the “Authority & Ask” Strategy and the The “Curiosity Close”, join the list now and get VIP tips weekly that are only available to my insiders. Plus, you'll get access to deeper insights and strategies to level up your marketing.